Header tag

Saturday 25 January 2020

Review: Star Trek Picard, Episode 1: Remembrance

CONTAINS SPOILERS

Star Trek's latest series, "Star Trek Picard" is an Amazon Prime exclusive - for the UK, this is a long way from the BBC2 once-a-week episode on Thursday evenings (which I eagerly watched) - and shows how far Star Trek has travelled from its syndicated roots.  I watched the first half of this episode on my mobile phone, then finished off the episode on following day at home on TV.

Star Trek Picard is also a considerable distance from its predecessors.  For the first time since Star Trek Voyager, we have a series which is set after the Voyager/TNG/DS9 era - Enterprise and Discovery were both prequels.  This is a real blast of fresh air - this series is not saddled with all the issues of making its continuity fit with already-known events, and having to fit everything in to a huge narrative.  And the best part of this is that STP sets up its own universe very quickly:  the Romulan sun (or, more accurately, star) has gone supernova and there's been a forced relocation of the Romulan population.  Admiral Picard now lives in a chateau in France, with a sizeable vineyard (as suggested in the TNG episode All Good Things), with a Romulan family.  The exact relationship here, and the personal story of how the Romulans came to live with Picard aren't clear - yet.


Much of the backstory is related during a media interview between a journalist and Picard, as he explains how Starfleet abandoned their mission to rescue the Romulans when they were needed most.  Events took a turn for the worse when the Romulan rescue mission was sabotaged - mortally - by synthetics who hacked into the Mars defence network and blew up the colony on Mars.  This has led to a galaxy-wide ban on the development of synthetics, and leads to bad blood between the Romulans and any remaining synths.

There's a parallel plot concerning a young lady called Dahj.  As she learns that her application to the Daystrom institute has been accepted, mysterious ninja assassins beam into her apartment, kill her boyfriend and attempt to either kill or kidnap her.  In a surprise development, she's able to defeat them in hand-to-hand combat (despite having a bag over her head) and realises that she isn't all that she thought.  Further developments follow as she starts having visions of Picard, and determines to track him down when she sees his broadcast interview with the journalist.

Picard is having bad dreams involving Data (who sacrificed himself at the end of Nemesis), and in one interesting dream, sees Data painting a picture - which Picard later realises is a painting that Data completed while he was alive and which now hangs on the walls of Picard's chateau.


The story develops at a measured pace - there are the high-energy phaser fire and hand-to-hand combat scenes, but there are also lengthy dialogue scenes, but these do serve to unpack this new world, and to further the plot in a sensible and plausible way.  Dahj meets Picard, and the two of them attempt to work out how they are actually connected.  There's a bit of the mysterious (which is a new twist for the generally straightforward science-and-logic format of Star Trek), but Picard realises that Dahj is the woman in Data's paintings - and, in a twist that I'm pleased to have spotted - Data painted two identical pictures (one in Chateau Picard, one in the Starfleet Archive).  

As Picard and Dahj start to come to terms with Dahj's true nature - she is a synthetic (android) - Dahj is caught and killed by the Romulan ninja assassins who have been chasing her down.  Picard has a lengthy and revealing conversation with an AI professor at the Daystrom institute, in which he asks about producing an android from flesh and blood, and gets a long but informative 'no'.  Bruce Maddox (TNG Measure of a Man) has been working on this idea, but has not made any progress.  However, it transpires that Dahj was one of a pair - twins - in the same way as there are two identical paintings of her (painted by Data, and titled "Daughter").

There are some overtones of Blade Runner here (I've never seen it), especially as we discover that Dahj's twin is living and working on a Romulan colony which - in the episode's final reveal - is built inside the remnants of a Borg cube.  The final scene, starting with two dangerous-looking spacecraft (the latest version of the Romulan warbird) moving through a cloaking field and entering a large, dark space station is filled with tension and the slow, steady reveal of the cube is shot in the style of the opening of First Contact, with a musical score that is very reminiscent of the Borg theme.  It's a dramatic conclusion to a great opening episode, and I'm looking forward to the rest of the series.

For those who were expecting to see more of the characters from previous Star Trek series - Seven of Nine, for example - you'll be disappointed.  This is very much the start of a long series (Star Trek has had mixed form with series-long arcs) and the trailer is for the whole series, not for episode one.  There's plenty in this first episode, though, and there is much to be hopeful about.

Friday 24 January 2020

Project Management: A Trip To The Moon

Scene: meeting room, some people dialling in remotely. The plan is to launch a manned rocket to the moon, and the project manager (PM) is kicking off the project.
PM "Right, team, let's plan this space journey to the moon. What kind of fuel will we use in our rocket?"
Designer 'Before I answer that, we want to discuss the colour of the nose cone. The design is to paint it blue.'
PM "Okay, blue is fine. Have you had any thoughts about the engine?"
Designer 'No, but we actually think a red nosecone might be better.'
PM "Noted. Let's move on from that, and come back to it nearer the launch time."
Marketing: We thought blue. Now, how we will we choose the pilots? PM "I was thinking that we would have a rigorous selection process."
Marketing: "We can do that. But we'd like to address the name of the spaceship. Our subsidiary want to call it the USSS Pegasus. We want to refer to it as the US Pegasus - the 'SS' was a suggestion from our previous owner. As this is a combined program, we're going to go with the US Pegasus."
PM "Noted. The US Pegasus. Now, about the pilots..."
Designer "And the name of the ship must be in blue text."
PM [making notes] "...blue text..."
Designer "To match the nose cone." PM "Now, circling back to the question of the pilots."
Stakeholder: "Oh, you can't say that. Circling back suggests that the ship isn't going to land on the moon." PM "Sure. So let's go on to the pilots?"
Stakeholder; "Yes, we can sort that out." PM "Thanks. Now - timelines. Do you have a target date for landing on the moon?" Stakeholder; "Yes, we want to land on 28 July, 2020. When do you need to launch?"
PM "How long will the flight take?" Stakeholder "That depends on the fuel." PM "Doesn't it depend on the engine?" Marketing "Possibly. But it's important that we land on 28 July." Stakeholder "Yes. 28 July. We've set that date with our president. It's his birthday"
PM "So who can give me the launch date?"
Stakeholder "Well, we expected you to provide that." PM "Okay, let's assume it takes four days to reach the moon. Can you have everything built and fuelled by then?" Stakeholder "And we'll want to check everything works." PM "Like a test launch?" Marketing "Oh no, we can't have a test launch. We can't have our competitors knowing what we're doing."
PM "No test launch?" Marketing "No." PM "And the pilots?" Stakeholder "I'm working on it." PM "And the fuel?" Stakeholder "I'll find somebody. Somebody somewhere must know something about it."
Marketing "And we'll need hourly readouts on speed. Preferably minute by minute. And oxygen levels; distance from the earth; internal and external temperatures. All those things." PM "Are you interested in the size of the engine?"
Stakeholder "We've been planning this for six months already. We know it'll need an engine." Engineer; "Sorry I'm late, I've just joined." PM "Thanks for joining. We're just discussing the rocket engine. Do you know what size it will be?" Engineer: "Big." PM "Big enough?" Engineer: "Yes. 1000 cubic units. Big enough." PM: "Great. Thanks. Let's move on." Stakeholder: "Wait, let's just check on that detail. Are you sure?"

Engineer; "Yes. I've done the calculations. It's big enough." Stakeholder: "To get to the moon?" Engineer: "Yes." Stakeholder: "And back?" Engineer: "Yes." Designer: "Even if we have blue text instead of red?"

Engineer: "Yes."
Marketing; "What about if we have red text."
Engineer; "The colour of the text isn't going to affect the engine performance." Stakeholder "Are you sure?"
Engineer: "We're not burning the paint as fuel. We're not painting the engine. We're good." PM: "Thank you. Now; how much fuel do you need?"
Engineer: "That depends. How quickly do you want to get there?" PM: "We need to land on the moon on 28 July 2020. I've estimated a four-day flight time." Engineer; "I'd make it five days, to be on the safe side, and I would calculate 6000 units of class-one fuel, approximately." PM: "Okay, that sounds reasonable. Will the number of pilots affect the fuel calculation?" Engineer: "Yes, but it won't significantly change the 6000 units estimate. When you know the number and mass of the pilots, we can calculate the fuel tank size we'll need."
Stakeholder; "But we won't know that until launch." PM: "Until launch?" Stakeholder: "Yes. We don't know how many people we want to send to the moon until the day of the launch." PM: "And the colour of the text? And the nose cone? And the actual text."
Stakeholder: "Will all depend on people we send."
PM: "No test launch?" Marketing; "No. We need this to be secret so that our competitors don't know what we're doing." PM: "So we're launching an undetermined number of people, in an untested rocket of unknown name and size, to the moon, with an approximate flight time and fuel load, at some point in the future."
Marketing: "But it must land on 28 July." PM: "2020, yes. Ok, We've run out of time for today, but let's catch up tomorrow with progress. Between now and then, let's work to decide some of the smaller details like the fuel and the engine, and tomorrow we can cover the main areas, such as the size of the rocket and where it's going. Thank you, everybody. Goodbye for now."